Asahi Legal

Redevelopment · 8 min read

Redevelopment on Government Leasehold Land: Collector NOC

Redevelopment on Government Leasehold Land: Collector NOC

A large number of older housing societies in Mumbai, including many in Bandra, do not own the land under their buildings. The land belongs to the State Government and was given to the society decades ago on lease or as “Occupancy Class II” land, administered by the Collector of Mumbai City or Mumbai Suburban District. Can such a society redevelop like any other? In brief: yes, but not freely. Class II and government leasehold land carry restrictions on transfer and redevelopment that need the Collector’s permission and, usually, payment of a premium. The cleaner route is often to convert the land to Occupancy Class I (in effect freehold) under the Maharashtra Land Revenue (Conversion of Occupancy Class-II and Leasehold Lands into Occupancy Class-I Lands) Rules, 2019, by paying a conversion premium. Societies should settle tenure, lease rent and premium questions before inviting developers, because those costs shape every offer.

Why tenure matters

Classes of land under the Land Revenue Code

Section 29 of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966 (MLRC) classifies persons holding land from the State into occupants Class I, occupants Class II and Government lessees. Class I occupancy is heritable and transferable without restriction. Class II occupancy is heritable, but transfer is restricted and generally needs the sanction of the Collector or the Government. Government lessees hold under the terms of their lease.

Land given to housing societies at concessional rates was usually granted on Class II or leasehold terms. The 7/12 extract or property card, and the lease deed or grant order, will show which.

What the restriction means in practice

On Class II or government leasehold land, the Collector’s permission is generally required to sell, transfer or mortgage a flat, or to redevelop the building. Permission typically comes with a demand for a share of the gain, often called unearned income or premium, and with conditions in the grant. A developer will not commit funds, and a bank will not lend against the sale component, until this is resolved. For this reason, tenure is a threshold issue, not a detail for later.

Option 1: Redevelop with the Collector’s permission

The society may remain on Class II or leasehold tenure and seek the Collector’s permission for redevelopment on the terms of the grant and current government policy. Points to expect:

Option 2: Convert to Class I before redevelopment

The 2019 Conversion Rules

The Revenue and Forest Department notified the Conversion Rules on 8 March 2019, under Sections 29A and 328 of the MLRC. They apply to land granted for agricultural, residential, commercial or industrial use on Occupancy Class II or leasehold rights. The holder applies to the District Collector, who verifies the land and the grant conditions. If there is no unregularised breach, or the breach has been regularised, the Collector converts the land to Class I by order after the premium is paid (Rule 3). Amounts paid earlier for change of use or for converting leasehold to Class II are adjusted.

The 2019 Rules prescribed premium as a percentage of land value under the Annual Statement of Rates. For residential land held by a co-operative housing society, whether Class II or leasehold, the rate was 15 per cent if the application was made within three years of publication, rising sharply thereafter.

The 2024 amnesty for housing societies

In March 2024, the State reduced the premium for housing societies. The Second Amendment Rules dated 16 March 2024 set the premium for residential land granted to a co-operative housing society at:

Society’s choice Premium (% of ready reckoner land value)
Opting for self-redevelopment 5%
Not opting for self-redevelopment 10%

The 2024 Rules attached conditions. A society undertaking self-redevelopment had to begin within two years of the conversion order, extendable by two years. Where additional FSI was available in redevelopment, 25 per cent of it had to be made available at government rates for beneficiaries under the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana; breach could lead to forfeiture of the premium and reversion to Class II. The concessional rates applied to applications received up to 30 September 2024.

Later extension and changes: check before applying

The concessional window has since been extended. An amendment notification reported to be dated 30 April 2026 extends certain conversion deadlines from 31 December 2025 to 31 December 2026 and refines eligibility for housing societies. Which rates, deadlines and conditions (including the PMAY requirement) now apply to a particular society should be confirmed from the notified text. A society relying on the concessional rate should obtain a copy of the current notification from the Collector’s office before passing resolutions or paying.

Lease rent: a separate liability

Conversion does not wipe out past dues. Many Mumbai societies on government land have disputed lease rent for years.

In Vrindavan CHSL v. State of Maharashtra, 2024:BHC-OS:10107-DB, decided in July 2024, a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court (B.P. Colabawalla and Somasekhar Sundaresan, JJ.) upheld the use of ready reckoner land values to revise lease rent under the 2012 Government Resolution, holding that the State is entitled to a reasonable return on its land. But the Court struck down the clause allowing lease rent to be reset every five years, because it conflicted with the bargain in the lease deeds.

In December 2025, according to a report in The Realty Today, the State issued a Government Resolution revising lease rent for Class II government land in Greater Mumbai where long-term leases have not expired, so that rent is charged only on a 25 per cent government share of land value. Societies should obtain the current lease rent demand in writing and reconcile it with this policy.

A worked example (hypothetical)

Suppose a society of 40 members in the suburbs sits on 2,000 sq m of Collector leasehold land, and the ready reckoner land rate is Rs 1,50,000 per sq m.

The society must then decide who bears it. In developer-led redevelopment, it is common to negotiate that the developer pays the conversion premium and arrears as part of the project cost. In any event, the figure should be known before tenders are issued.

Practical steps before inviting developers

Step 1: Establish tenure from documents

Collect the grant order, lease deed and renewals, 7/12 extract or property card, and any earlier Collector permissions. Confirm whether the land is Class II, leasehold, or partly each.

Step 2: Audit compliance with grant conditions

List every transfer of flats, whether permission was taken, any change of use, and any additional construction. Unregularised breaches can block conversion under Rule 3 of the 2019 Rules.

Step 3: Settle lease rent and dues

Obtain a written statement of lease rent and other dues from the Collector, and check it against the 2024 judgment and the December 2025 policy.

Step 4: Decide the tenure route by general body resolution

Compare redevelopment with permission against conversion to Class I, including the premium and who pays. Record the decision in a general body resolution.

Step 5: Apply to the Collector

File the conversion or permission application with complete documents, and follow it up until the Collector passes an order.

Step 6: Only then issue the tender

Build the tenure cost and the expected Collector conditions into the feasibility report and tender, so that offers are comparable. The general body meeting to select a developer must then follow Rule 106C-13 of the MCS Rules and the directives issued by the State Government under Section 79A of the MCS Act.

Checklist

Document or issue Status to confirm
Grant order and lease deed Tenure type, term, renewal and conditions
7/12 extract or property card Class II or leasehold entry
Flat transfers Permissions taken or regularisation needed
Lease rent Current demand and arrears
Conversion premium Rate, deadline and conditions under current notification
Developer’s obligation Who pays premium, arrears and Collector charges

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a society on Collector land redevelop without converting to Class I?

Yes, in principle, with the Collector’s permission and on payment of the charges demanded under the grant and policy. Many societies find conversion simpler, because it removes the continuing restrictions on transfer and redevelopment.

What premium does a housing society pay to convert to Class I?

Under the 2024 amendment, 5 per cent of the ready reckoner land value for societies opting for self-redevelopment and 10 per cent for others, for applications within the notified window. The window has been extended by later notifications, so the current rate and deadline should be confirmed from the notified text.

Does conversion end the society’s liability for old lease rent?

No. Arrears are a separate liability and should be settled or reconciled. The Bombay High Court in 2024 upheld ready reckoner based lease rent but struck down five-yearly revisions.

Who usually pays the conversion premium in redevelopment?

It is a matter of negotiation. In developer-led projects, societies commonly require the developer to bear it as a project cost, and the development agreement should say so expressly.

What if earlier flat transfers were made without permission?

The Collector may reject conversion until breaches are regularised. The society should identify them early and apply for regularisation.

This article is for general information and is not legal advice.

Asahi Legal regularly acts in matters of this kind before the Bombay High Court, NCLT/NCLAT and other forums. For a personal consultation, you may book an appointment.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice or an invitation to engage the firm. Laws and judgments change; please obtain specific legal advice before acting.

Chat on WhatsApp