Asahi Legal

Arbitration · 10 min read

Section 11: Appointment of Arbitrator by the Court

Section 11: Appointment of Arbitrator by the Court

An arbitration clause is only useful if a tribunal can actually be constituted. When the other side refuses to appoint its arbitrator, ignores a notice, or insists on appointing a sole arbitrator of its own choosing, the party wanting to arbitrate turns to Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The short answer to how a Section 11 appointment of arbitrator works is this: after the agreed appointment procedure fails, a party may apply to the High Court (or, in an international commercial arbitration, the Supreme Court), which looks only at whether an arbitration agreement prima facie exists and whether the application is within three years, and then appoints an independent arbitrator. Almost everything else is left to the tribunal. This article explains when to apply, what the court will and will not examine, the limitation period, and where unilateral appointment clauses now stand.

How Section 11 is structured

Section 11 begins with party autonomy and then supplies a fall-back.

Under Section 11(7), a decision on an application under sub-sections (4), (5) or (6) is final, and no appeal, including a Letters Patent appeal, lies against it. In Hindustan Construction Co. v. Bihar Rajya Pul Nirman Nigam (2025) the Supreme Court held that neither a review nor an appeal lies against an order appointing an arbitrator under Section 11.

When to apply: the steps before the petition

Step 1: Invoke arbitration under Section 21

Under Section 21, unless otherwise agreed, arbitral proceedings commence on the date the respondent receives a request for the dispute to be referred to arbitration. The notice should identify the clause, describe the disputes, and propose an arbitrator or call on the other side to appoint one.

Step 2: Follow the contractual procedure

If the clause requires a pre-arbitral step, such as negotiation or a reference to an engineer, record that it was attempted or why it was futile.

Step 3: Wait for the thirty days (or the agreed period)

Count thirty days from receipt of the request under Section 11(4) or 11(5), or the period the clause provides. A petition filed before the other side has failed to act is premature.

Step 4: File the petition

Annex the contract, the Section 21 notice with proof of delivery and any reply, and state why the court has jurisdiction, which in a domestic arbitration usually follows the seat.

What the court examines, and what it does not

Prima facie existence of an arbitration agreement

Section 11(6A), inserted in 2015, confines the court to examining the existence of an arbitration agreement. In In re Interplay between Arbitration Agreements under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 (2023 INSC 1066, decided 13 December 2023), a seven-judge bench held that an unstamped or insufficiently stamped arbitration agreement is not void ab initio. Non-stamping is a curable defect, and objections on stamp duty are for the arbitral tribunal, not the referral court.

Krish Spinning: the referral court’s limited role

In SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish Spinning (2024 INSC 532), a three-judge bench held that the inquiry at the Section 11 stage is limited to the prima facie existence of the arbitration agreement. The insurer argued that the claimant had signed a discharge voucher, so the dispute had been settled by accord and satisfaction. The Court held that this plea does not question the existence of the arbitration agreement, which is separate from and survives the underlying contract, and must be decided by the tribunal. The Court also disapproved of the older tests under which referral courts screened claims as “ex-facie meritless”, because they required the court to examine contested facts.

What remains for the court

A referral court can still decline to appoint where, on a plain reading, there is no arbitration agreement at all. In 2025 the Supreme Court held, for instance, that a clause saying arbitration “may be sought” was not a binding arbitration agreement (BGM and M-RPL-JMCT v. Eastern Coalfields), and that the mere use of the word “arbitration” does not create one without a clear intention to be bound (Alchemist Hospitals v. ICT Health Technology). These are questions of existence, not merits.

Limitation for a Section 11 petition

The Act does not prescribe a period for Section 11 applications. In Arif Azim Co. Ltd. v. Aptech Ltd. (2024 INSC 155, decided 1 March 2024), the Supreme Court held that Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963 applies: three years from when the right to apply accrues. That right accrues only after a valid notice invoking arbitration has been sent and the other party has failed or refused to comply with it. The Court described three years as unduly long and suggested that Parliament prescribe a specific period.

Arif Azim also said the court could refuse to refer claims that were ex facie dead on the date arbitration commenced. In Krish Spinning, decided later in 2024, the Court confined the referral court to checking whether the Section 11 petition itself is within time, leaving the question whether the underlying claims are time-barred to the arbitral tribunal.

Keep two clocks in mind:

Clock Governs Period
Limitation for the claim Whether the claim itself is time-barred (decided by the tribunal) Usually 3 years from accrual of the cause of action; arbitration commences on receipt of the Section 21 notice
Limitation for the Section 11 petition Whether the court will entertain the appointment application 3 years under Article 137, from the failure to act on a valid Section 21 notice

A worked example (hypothetical)

Suppose a contractor’s final bill is rejected on 10 October 2025. It sends a Section 21 notice, received by the employer on 12 January 2026, proposing three names for a sole arbitrator. The employer does not respond within thirty days. The right to apply accrues on the expiry of those thirty days, in mid-February 2026, and the Section 11 petition should be filed within three years of that date. Separately, because arbitration commenced on 12 January 2026, the claim itself was brought well within three years of the rejection.

Unilateral appointments

From Perkins to CORE

Under Section 12(5) read with the Seventh Schedule, a person whose relationship with a party or counsel falls within the listed categories is ineligible to be appointed, unless the parties waive this by an express agreement in writing after the dispute has arisen. In Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v. HSCC (India) Ltd. (2019), the Supreme Court held that a party, or its official, who has an interest in the outcome cannot unilaterally appoint a sole arbitrator.

In Central Organisation for Railway Electrification v. ECI-SPIC-SMO-MCML (JV) (2024 INSC 857, decided 8 November 2024), a five-judge Constitution Bench went further. By majority, it held:

Justices Hrishikesh Roy and P.S. Narasimha wrote separate opinions that differed from the majority on some of these points.

Bhadra International (2026): no waiver by conduct

In Bhadra International (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Airports Authority of India (2026 LiveLaw (SC) 4, reported 6 January 2026), a bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K.V. Viswanathan held that participation in the arbitration, filing a statement of claim, recording “no objection” in a procedural order or seeking an extension of the mandate under Section 29A does not amount to a waiver under the proviso to Section 12(5). Waiver must be by an express agreement in writing. An ineligible arbitrator lacks jurisdiction, and the objection may be raised at any stage, including in a Section 34 challenge to the award.

What this means for a Section 11 petition

If the clause lets one side name a sole arbitrator, or forces the other to pick from a list it controls, the affected party should object in writing and, if necessary, apply under Section 11(6) for an independent appointment. In Offshore Infrastructures v. BPCL (2025), the Supreme Court held that the ineligibility of the named arbitrator does not invalidate the arbitration clause itself; the court can appoint a neutral arbitrator.

What about the proposed amendments?

A draft Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Bill was released for public consultation on 18 October 2024. Until any amendment is enacted and brought into force, the Act as amended in 2015, 2019 and 2021 continues to govern Section 11 applications.

Checklist before filing

Frequently Asked Questions

When can I file a Section 11 petition?

After the agreed appointment procedure fails. Typically this means the other side has not appointed its arbitrator, or agreed on a sole arbitrator, within thirty days of receiving your written request, or has failed to act under the procedure in the contract.

What is the limitation period for a Section 11 application?

Three years under Article 137 of the Limitation Act, counted from when the other party fails or refuses to act on a valid notice invoking arbitration, as held in Arif Azim Co. Ltd. v. Aptech Ltd. (2024).

Will the court decide whether my claim is time-barred or has been settled?

Generally not. After Krish Spinning (2024), questions such as accord and satisfaction and whether the claims are time-barred are left to the arbitral tribunal. The court checks only the prima facie existence of the arbitration agreement and whether the petition itself is in time.

Can the other party appoint a sole arbitrator on its own?

A party interested in the outcome cannot unilaterally appoint a sole arbitrator (Perkins Eastman, 2019), and the Constitution Bench in CORE (2024) held that unilateral appointment clauses in public-private contracts violate Article 14, with the ruling applying prospectively to appointments made after 8 November 2024. Any waiver of ineligibility must be an express written agreement made after the dispute arose.

Can I appeal an order appointing an arbitrator?

No. Section 11(7) makes the decision final and bars appeals, including Letters Patent appeals. Objections to the tribunal’s jurisdiction can be raised before the tribunal under Section 16.

This article is for general information and is not legal advice.

Asahi Legal regularly acts in matters of this kind before the Bombay High Court, NCLT/NCLAT and other forums. For a personal consultation, you may book an appointment.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice or an invitation to engage the firm. Laws and judgments change; please obtain specific legal advice before acting.

Chat on WhatsApp